Looking forward to a stress-free Christmas, Archie is in a bind when both Betty and Veronica buy him a matching sweater and each wants him to wear his matching sweater with her at the mall. He keeps going into the bathroom to change depending in which girl is near, but a mall security guard thinks he's shoplifting.; Veronica complains that Archie doesn't listen to her, which of course he doesn't. But when a mysterious Christmas present shows up at his house, Archie takes the present to Pop's to get opinions on whether he should open it early or not.; Mr. Lodge and Smithers panic when Archie leaves the Lodges' house with a tool kit in hand.; Archie and Veronica both hide their shame as to why they aren't kissing on a date-- Archie has a cold and Veronica has onion breath.