Veronica has created her deadliest batch of Christmas cookies ever. Archie and Betty come up with a way to dispose of the cookies without hurting her feelings: get Chuck and Moose to steal them and convince Ronnie there are "cookie thieves" in the neighborhood.; During a Christmas show at an orphanage, Betty meets a girl who is sad because she doesn't have a father. Using the example of electricity, Betty teaches the girl that God sends out signals everywhere and that God can do what no earthly father can do.; Due to a bright idea by two department store clerks, Veronica winds up giving Betty a gift that she really wanted for herself, and vice versa.; When Betty and Veronica wear identical skating outfits, Veronica tries to ruin Betty's outfit.